A new machine was recently installed in the Rocky Top dining hall.

It’s a Califia Farms milk dispenser with three new options — oat milk, soy milk and chocolate pea milk.

This is in addition to the five milks already available in the dining hall — skim milk, reduced fat milk, TruMoo chocolate milk and two types of almond milk.

As I surveyed my options, it dawned on me — I have decision fatigue.

Almond is slightly nuttier, oat is slightly thicker, soy tastes like regular milk, and I have no interest in finding out what pea milk tastes like. But blindfold me and ask me the difference between all of them? No chance.

I reached for the soy, pushed the lever, and … nothing. I guess they were all out. You know what? Who needs milk anyway?

I walked back to my table and my roommate asked me what milk I got. I told her none — they were out of soy milk.

“Why didn’t you just get regular milk?”

The shock. The horror.

“Ew,” I heard myself say. “I don’t drink cow’s milk.”

A wave of guilt washed over me. People have been drinking cow’s milk since the dawn of time. I don’t think it’s gross.

But my knee-jerk reaction to the mere suggestion of adding some to my coffee indicates that I may have some complicated and unexplored feelings about cow’s milk.

Once ruling American kitchens, cow’s milk is just … out.

It feels like the only people drinking milk are farmers and babies. It used to be “drink your milk to get big and strong.” But in 2026, I think most people would rather light themselves on fire before they drink full-fat cow’s milk. And with all the options available, you’ll never have to.

In the 90s, cow’s milk was what the substitutes are today. In partnership with popular celebrities, the California Milk Processor Board released the iconic “Got Milk?” campaign.

Beyonce, Jennifer Aniston, Naomi Campbell, Gisele Bündchen. Clad in designer outfits, celebrities proudly modeled milk mustaches, convincing consumers that no matter how glamorous you were, the sexiest thing you could do was meet your daily calcium intake.

Shaquille O’Neal, Serena Williams, Tom Brady, David Beckham. Cow’s milk wasn’t just stylish. It was functional. It fueled high-power athletes to perform at the highest level. If you didn’t want weak bones, you drank milk. If you didn’t drink milk, you were practically asking to catch a bad case of osteoporosis.

The average adult is recommended to have 1,000 mg of calcium daily. Cow’s milk, calcium’s resident poster child, contains approximately 300 mg of calcium per 8 ounces.

Per 8 ounces, original Silk Almondmilk contains 470 mg of calcium, Silk Soymilk contains 470 mg of calcium, and Califia Farms Oatmilk contains 270 mg of calcium.

So, in terms of nutritional value, the substitutes don’t seem to be that far behind. In fact, when comparing caloric value, almond milk seems like the better option. Whole milk typically contains almost double the calories of competing beverages.

So not only has cow’s milk been outdone, but it’s also a fading trend.

Gluten-free, paleo, keto, vegan. The most popular contemporary diet trends revolve around plant-based substitutes. Cut out dairy, meat, sugar — replace it all with a powder you can buy by the pound at Costco.

Ozempic, Wegovy, Mounjaro. I don’t need to spell it out for you. The direction of the wellness industry today is clear. If engine oil were low-calorie, plant-based and tasted like Diet Coke, people would drink it.

Milk started it, and countless corporations followed suit. An entire industry thrives on the idea that the original version isn’t good enough. Bread, ice cream, coffee, pasta — the macros aren’t what they could be. The calories could be lower. The protein could be higher.

Once you realize how much better something could be — how much better you could be — the switch makes itself.

Sure, the cultural perception of milk has changed. I don’t remember the last time I heard someone order whole milk at Starbucks. But it’s not just that.

There is something gross about the idea of drinking milk from a cow. When I drink it straight, it feels wrong. No matter how cold it is, it tastes lukewarm. It just feels wrong — unnatural. Which, for obvious reasons, is ironic.

Maybe it’s the fact that it comes from an animal. Maybe I need to spend some time on a farm. Maybe I feel bad for the cow.

All I know is, almond milk seems cleaner, healthier and skinnier.

Occasionally, you drink a glass with a warm chocolate chip cookie — for nostalgia’s sake. But other than that, more for the babies and farmers.

Milk being phased out isn’t necessarily a bad thing. Hey, I’m sure the cows don’t mind. But amidst discourse that we are becoming less and less human, it’s worth noting that our collective milk aversion is rooted in a desire to be skinny and “it feels warm.”

UT is indulging our changing preferences with state-of-the-art Califia Farms machines in dining halls across campus. Let them fry in Reese, but God forbid I have to start my morning without chocolate pea milk.

I don’t hate the substitutes — as we’ve established, they provide numerous health benefits. But I miss the simplicity of cow’s milk. There was only one option, and you felt good about choosing it.

When I open my phone for a dopamine hit and an escape from life, I’m assaulted by the unsolicited opinions of every fitness influencer, nutrition coach and “doctor” on the internet. They spout narratives that contradict years of successful evolution — avocados will kill you, store-bought bread will kill you, peanut butter will kill you, seed oils will kill you.

No matter how ill-informed, every terrible take is delivered with absolute certainty and morbid finality, which makes navigating health and wellness feel like disassembling a bomb. One wrong choice and you’ve screwed yourself for life. Or at least for spring break, which is only two short weeks away.

Maybe I’m just having trouble letting go. When times change, they demand that you change with them.

I have been bombarded with decisions I didn’t want to make, filled with facts I didn’t want to know and exposed to nutrition labels I didn’t want to read.

Even if it’s for the best — even if you are optimizing your health and wellness — you mourn the simple life.

A life that wasn’t about optimization or improvement, but rather about ease. There was no guilt around ignorance. Milk was one less decision you had to weigh. One less right choice you had to make.

Is this what being an adult is? Black coffee? The constant weight of choice? Maybe.

Maybe in 30 years, they will have an almond milk substitute. Then in 60 years, an almond milk substitute substitute. And then in 90 years — you get the picture.

While I would love to combat overconsumption and diet culture, as a consumer, I just don’t feel like that’s my responsibility. The milk revolution has come, and there isn’t anything anyone can do about it.

Claire Thatcher is a freshman at UT this year studying journalism and media. She can be reached at [email protected].

Columns and letters of The Daily Beacon are the views of the individual and do not necessarily reflect the views of the Beacon or the Beacon’s editorial staff.